Tom & Jerry's Bar & Grill

Love this place !! Food is good , wait staff is great! Grilled salmon is my choice prob once a week ! Highly recommend!

Watered down booze. Had dinner and drinks at the bar with my wife. Asked for a shot of Wild Turkey 101, my wife had a tequila, and bought a shot for the bartender. I noticed the bartenders face when she poured my drink...looked long at the bottle. I thought the shot of Turkey looked a little cloudy. So, we clanged glasses and drank up. I told the bartender that I just took a shot of water...that was not Turkey. I was expecting her to say hey I thought that shot looked discolored or something and offer me another, but, she said well that was the last shot in the bottle...it is what it is... Then just went over to the regulars and chatted with them and ignored us. Very weird vibe. But I think she must have known they water down the booze and had a nervous reaction when I mentioned my shot tasted like water. We tipped her anyway. Spent about $125 with food and drinks. We won't go back and I never write reviews.

Seems like a typical local bar. The staff was friendly, and at the time I went, it wasn't too loud. Standard bar menu, but I'd go back. Nice stop for a quick beer or meeting up with friends.

Excellent fresh food & friendly service
I got the Gorgonzola salad (very fresh lettuce, delicious grilled chicken on top), my husband got the shepherd's pie (also excellent), 2 teenage boys got burgers which were "good" (high praise). From out of town coming from a soccer game, I am bookmarking this restaurant & would come again if in the area.

I am giving this bar 4 star a because to me, the pros outweigh the cons:
Pros:
-have a pool table (only one but that's still a plus in my book)
-friendly service for the most part
-can be a fun place to have a drink with friends
-good place to watch a game & have some wings
-the chicken wrap we got here was good
Cons:
-bathroom is a single stall and wasn't clean the last few times I've been there
-the draft beer always tastes slightly off, can't put my finger on what the problem is
-there's a wall to separate families who are dining from the slightly more rowdy bar crowd

What a hole.
Taps are switched.
Goose IPA is Sweetwater and vise versa.
No one knows better. Including bartender who was completely uninterested and defensive. I know my beer. These guys got it mixed up- period.
1 star for the inability to keep your taps straight and for a dipshit bartender who couldnt give a damn.
Will not return.

I have been going here for over 13 years and I love it, great people they really get to know you after a while. They have great food sometimes a little slow but I still recommend it to everyone. They are one of the only bars still open in brewster and hope they continue to operate as the pandemic continues!

Bartender Gina, was the most horrible, rude, uninterested, sexist, disgusting customer service worker I've ever met in my whole entire life. What I've noticed was the way she treated the male customers. Like they're best friends but she couldn't even look me in the eyes when I tried talking to her.

I didn't know that because you fuck the owner of the bar means you get to treat customers however you wanted. I will never return.

The wings were hot and delicious and so were the fried pickles. Our server, Mary, is the best. I had a high maintenance order which she handled with a smile. She also joked and laughed with us. This was more like southern hospitality than typical northern attitude considering that I am in upstate NY. I will definitely come back.

I am confused as to how this server keeps her job. Perhaps she is the "Maggie" for whom the restaurant is named, as there could be no other explanation. After waiting several minutes, the server finally noticed us and asked "Can I help you?" When I told her that we would like to be seated, she rudely said "So sit!" She remained brusque in her delivery and movements throughout the meal, including flinging menus and the check. Never once did she ask if we needed anything or were satisfied. Needless to say, she is the single reason we won't be returning to Maggie's/Tom and Jerry's.