Sal's Pizza

Best pizza ever.

We are from out of town and we're craving pizza. Not many options around but we decided to try Sal's. Delicious with every bite!

Once a year, we get pizza in January at our family reunion. The last few years the other places we chose were mediocre. NOT SAL'S! They had great deals. Friendly staff answering the phone. The pizza came promptly to our hotel and it was still PIPING HOT!

Everyone really loved it!

Thanks for a great end to our evening! And the leftovers were amazing for breakfast lol.

See you next year

Always quick delivery always hot and fresh. We love the thin crust pizzas. The tossed salad is a great bargain too.

Overall Sal's pizza is pretty good (maybe a bit too much sauce for my liking) but the toppings were fresh and proportioned well. We ordered the breaded veggie combo for an appetizer. I should know better to order fried foods like this for delivery as the mushrooms, zucchini and cauliflower were mushy and no longer crisp.
Ordering online was super easy and our food came right on time.

Got takeout and delivery here multiple times during the course of a hospital stay. Great pizza, generally very fast delivery.

Sause was tasteless pizza was warm cheese was herd and the green peppers where to chunky and bitter

Best pizza on the planet - and I know pizza. I'm from Chicago. From the friendly gal that takes your phone order to the delivery person with your order, every one has been super kind. Aside from Italian pastas, there are Mexican items, too. Daily specials, also. Go for it!

We ordered a large par-baked stuffed pizza and what we received was a pizza without sauce, you read that correctly, no sauce. In addition, we didn't received no instructions on how to finish baking it.
Contacted the owner and explained what happened. He apologized and said we should have received sauce and baking instructions. To correct this he gave us a $12 credit to be used the next time we order. Mind you the inedible pizza we received was almost $30.
What we felt he should have done was at a minimum given us a correctly made pizza equal to what we ordered.
We have always enjoyed their food in the past and have even recommended them to others but now we not sure we can do that. In fact, not sure if we will ever go back.
Please consider this experience when you are deciding on a restaurant in Waukesha.

Ordered a pizza and panzarotti yesterday, Delicious. The Panzarotti is the best I've had, and the pizza sauce to dip it in, is the best too. Very generous serving. The gal at the counter understands customer service very well. First time ordering here, we will be back. We were there in the afternoon on a tuesday when one would think it would be dead, nope, a steady stream of customers. I am looking forward to trying some of their other dishes.

Done ordering from here!! Have always loved their pizza but the last 2 times were horrible!! The 1st time the pizza wasn't cut and the toppings were off entirely. This time the pizza was cut messily and upon taking a bite - Hair was on it! Never again!!