Nino's New York Style Pizza

I ate there for the first time this afternoon. The crust was light and crispy. The sauce and ingredients were fresh and delicious. A beautiful clean shop. I will definitely be back.

My favorite local pizza shop. Pizza is always good. I've got a couple different sandwiches and each has been very good. Their sausage sandwich with peppers and onions is pretty awesome.

Went in and had their Sicilian pizza and also ordered spaghetti with Garlic and oil. The pizza was very good, a thick crust with nice crumb.
Sauce was not acidic, very nice overall.

As you can see from the photo the spaghetti had a lot of oil and perhaps I am expecting a lot from this dish at a pizzeria but the key to this dish is adding in some pasta water to emulsify the oil and coat the pasta.

They are very busy with to go orders which is always a good sign.
Would happily eat here again

I posted a not favorable review but it was for a Nino's Pizza in York, PA. Not realizing this was actually is a Lancaster restaurant. I couldn't delete my review so I'm changing it to say how nice the owner of the Lancaster restaurant was to reach out to me in such a nice way to say he didn't think I was their customer. Now, he knows customer service and I would recommend ya'all over the river give his place a try.

Was my first time I went there. The steak sandwiches were awful. No taste at all. Slice of pizza looked like a piece of cardboard with a bunch of mushrooms thrown on it . Won't go back again

Nothing special about their food. New York style pizza is always toasted but Ninos Pizza is extremely doughy and not flavorful. Idk if they're always in a rush but all you need to do is keep your pizza in the oven for a while longer to get a nice toasted bottom.

My last order was over the phone and a young girl answered sounding irritated and tried rushing me off the phone when I asked if I could pay over the phone. She insisted I pay in person for whatever reason. But I declined and she finally allowed me to pay over the phone only to mess my order up. After waiting nearly an hour to pick up my food she never charged me for my 2nd pizza and although I ordered regular pizzas I was charged for XL pizzas...when I brought this up I wasn't given anything for the inconvenience this caused. I was given a random pizza they had in the back AND charged full price. Lol

What a joke. Never again!

Just picked up a large Buffalo Chicken pizza at time agreed to. Size was fine. It is cold. The chicken pieces are sparse but large chunky chunks. Cheese skimpy. Used to have great food. Not any more!

Excellent food...very crowded and long-ish wait, but worth it! Fast service too. I'd definitely check it out if you are in NYC.

I started going there last week. I am a vegan so my choices there are limited. As long as aglio e olio (garlic and olive oil) are available, along with warm bread, and a salad, I am happy! If you love Italian food with Sicilian flavor, check out Nino's. Everything looks and smells delicious.

I've eaten pizza up and down the west and east coasts, trust me when I say this is the best pizza in Lancaster county. We were super bummed to see their neighbors Burts bottle shop go because a six pack and this pizza is the best Saturday night in vibe!