Gary's Ice Cream

The pricing makes no sense... I ordered a kiddie cup and it was $5. My friend got a bigger size and it was $6. It was a lot bigger than my kiddie cup. If I knew that I would have just paid the extra dollar for the larger size. Why is a kiddie cup $5?? Rip off if you ask me. If you come here to get ice cream might as well order a medium or large to make it worth your money. I added a picture for comparison, not the best pic but you can definitely tell the size difference. Aside from the pricing the ice cream was good.

My favorite ice cream place period! They have the best pistachio ice cream and coconut ice cream. If you like more of a sherbet then try out the orange sherbet.

Tasty and good quality ice cream but small for the price. Out of state people will be satisfied but New England ice cream hounds are used to double portion sizes.

Good quality spoons with no sharp edges. Loads of parking. Picnic tables in good repair but not the cleanest possible nor disgusting.

Great ice cream. Reasonably priced for outstanding quality. Good service.

The chocolate chip is fantastic. But I miss the small chocolate chips that the old Glennie's had.

Only complaint is that they should neaten up the outside spaces

Ice cream is good, but man, it is pricey. The kiddie scoop is $4.50 and everything added, cone, cup (if you have a little kid who, like mine, needs a cup to go along with the cone), and any sprinkles are .50c at minimum to add on. I have to roll my eyes a little at fifty cents for an extra cup, but whatever. Got an ice cream cookie sandwich which, again, was totally delicious but had the smallest, saddest smear of ice cream on it, and was $4. Lots of black on white signage about...everything. Where to park, what costs extra, where to sit, "use of picnic tables is at your own risk"... they're all so specific and there's so much of it that it seems like a joke but I think Gary just really likes signs or something.

Lime Rickey all summer long.
Some goose nips, You good.
Wish it was open in later months but it's cool.

Not a fan of their ice cream anymore. The people who work there are rude and act stuck up. They also just stare at you and don't even say "hi how are you".
I also heard some rumors about the owner so I will definitely not be returning.

If you choose any other ice cream stand instead of Gary's, you have made a sad mistake. They have been in business since 1973, they make all their own ice cream and toppings, their fruit ice creams are seasonal and prepared from the freshest of fruit, and their hot fudge is the real from-scratch deal.

In a state already known for the superb quality of its dairy farms and ice cream stands, Gary's is a full head above the others.

This was my 2nd visit to Gary's. The first time I got soft serve on a sugar cone. I ordered that today and Gary said "we don't do that" I told him I got it last time I was here and he told me I didn't as if I was an idiot. He then looked at my boyfriend who then confirmed that we both got soft serve on sugar cones. Gary then went off on a tangent about firing staff for doing so, specifically someone named Liam. I thought it was disgusting to speak so negatively of your own staff and to want to fire them over using the "wrong cone". I told him it wasn't a guy and he said only one girl works there and pointed at her. I was so uncomfortable because I didn't think a simple request would lead him to wanting to fire someone so this was my last visit. The guy is a horrible business owner who treats his customers horribly. No one looked happy there.

Okay portion sizes, but I've cream isnt very flavored (coffee, chocolate, and vanilla all taste the same). They don't offer many toppings either.