Menu
Review Highlights
“As close to Myles' pizza as you can get” in 4 reviews
“We ordered a classic supreme 9" pizza which was SO full of toppings the 2 of us were so full we ended up taking 3 pieces with us.” in 2 reviews
“Ryan, Jill and Erica are awesome.” in 2 reviews
Location & Hours
You Might Also Consider
in Chinese, Asian Fusion
in Sandwiches, Delis, Pizza
Amenities and More
Ask the Community
Yelp users haven’t asked any questions yet about Pizza Pub 516.
Recommended Reviews
Overall rating
33 reviews
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star
- T L.Perrysburg, OH13731Jan 23, 2024
I saw they had a lunch special, so I thought we'd try it. $7 for a one typing pizza and a pop. Absolutely delicious and what a, great deal. We got lucky and they were slow, so a normally louder page was pleasantly quiet. I highly recommend it for flavor and especially for a great value at lunch!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Kim W.OH, OH03Mar 10, 2024
I got a pizza and a salad from here today. The salad was really good. The pizza was awful. It had plenty of toppings but it was burned. We couldn't even eat the pizza. We won't go back
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Tony G.Whiting, IN020Aug 5, 2023
My wife and I went there on a Thursday night. Fairly busy, but the bartender took our drink order right away. Waitress eventually brought our drinks. She got one right. Ok, not a good start, but mistakes happen. We ordered pizza.
About 30 minutes later the waitress finally returned so I ordered and eventually received another drink. More than another 30 minutes pass so I go find the waitress to ask about the pizza. We're now more than an hour in. The waitress assures us our pizza is coming out next.
10 minutes or so later the waitress tells us someone else got our order by mistake. But they'll put another in right away. We have now been there at least an hour and a quarter.
We paid for the drinks and left.Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Ceila A.Terra Del Sol, Tucson, AZ1344313May 31, 2023
BEST PIZZA I ever had! I ordered a 12 inch pizza came out to $22.00 I also added mushrooms & chicken. BLOWN OUT OF MY MIND! This was seriously the best pizza ever. Definitely will be back!
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - QB P.Waterville, OH3295Jan 10, 2023
Meh. The garlic cheese bread looked amazing but lacked flavor and was just heavy bread. It did t have much butter or garlic taste. I thought the meat pizza was amazing and it even reminded me of the village idiots pizza a little. The other pizza we got was okay. May have been an off night. We also had some issues with the website and menu online. There were things mentioned but couldn't find them anywhere to order. Has potential but I would get a thin crust if available.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Mary A.Elmore, OH184Apr 7, 2023
stopped in to try the pizza and were very disappointed. Their prices were extremely high. We had two different menus and ordered and were told the price was higher than the one we looked at. The manager would not honor the lower price menu. Too bad we won't be back (also waitress spilled part of my drink on me and my purse) very poor customer service.
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - Claudia B.Broomfield, CO12960115Jun 18, 2021
While traveling partway across the country, we stopped in Toledo, Ohio for the night. It was late and we were both hungry. We found this place due to a simple Google search and hoped for the best. I got a side salad with garlic bread and pizza sauce and my partner got a meatball grinder. They were happy to make substitutions for us and the food was ready when they said it would be. Everything was delicious! Most notable was the amazing garlic bread. I ordered a half portion and it was literally half a loaf of bread! Just the right amount of garlic butter and cheese; it was perfect. We even saved a piece for breakfast.
Helpful 1Thanks 0Love this 0Oh no 0 - 176183437Sep 3, 2018
This just opened up right next to us, so we went in to try it. My husband LOVED it. Its super thick, deep dish style. For what it was, it was good. I am just not a huge fan of deep dish. That being said, the flavor was very good. I just couldn't eat more than a piece of it. They did have alarge selection of pretopped styles and a build your own option. Also, it is NOT cheap
Helpful 0Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0 - Robofcinci ..West Chester, OH0232Mar 29, 2022
Sat down at bar for about 10 minutes and the bartender completely ignored me. She messed with her phone a few times and talked to employees. I eventually just got up and left. It was very frustrating!!
Helpful 2Thanks 0Love this 1Oh no 0
You Might Also Consider
in Chicken Wings, Fast Food
in New American, Bars, Gastropubs