Eleventh Street Pizza - Downtown Miami

Cute little pizza shop in downtown. Their Pepperoni Pie with Hot Honey and Mushroom Truffle Oil pizzas are incredible. Thin, crispy and the flavor is amazing.

The only downside is the price point. 2 large pizzas for take out ends up being $90, very excessive, which includes a 10% take out fee.

Pizza- amazing. People- worth not coming back for.
We ordered a pepperoni & hot honey, onions on half (I'm allergic). Pizza comes out, we don't know where the onions are.... No biggie. We ask, which side has onions? 3 people, nobody knows and we get the answer "if it is the right or left you won't know the difference at this point"zzz not wrong so can yall show us?
Comes out, shines a flashlight. Can't tell (because there's onions on the whole dang pizza. At this stage, can you just remake, please? One of us is allergic. "Well, I'm not sure, lemme ask"
We wait 30 minutes, no direction on remaking a pizza. Walk back in, ask the correct pizza to be put in a Togo box.
Let the person know that I'm writing a review because of X,Y,Z listed above..... I'm then told it's my fault for not informing her of "said allergy" when we let them know that all it takes is a simple apology that they made a mistake on our pizza. I shouldn't have to tell someone it's an allergy for a pizza to be made correctly and then apologize because the pizza was made incorrectly the first time. Spent $70 to wait over an hour for our correct pizza. We let the person helping us know at this stage, we are just looking for an apology, nothing else. Response? Oh, well, I'm sorry. Honestly, too late. We've now spoken to 3 people about this.

Not in relation to my review but extremely disappointed they are also charging $2.50 for 2oz soufflé cups worth of marinara. Extreme rip off, in my opinion but to each business (this review isn't about this, only a statement).

Paying 47.20 for meatballs with burrata and a beer is absurdddddddd. First time I see a dinning fee more expensive than delivery.

The meatballs were fine but 30 something for meatballs insane were they mind blowing no... good yea... would I pay that again? Absolutely not.

I get it's a tourist trap area next to space and eleven but y'all must be on one to think this is normal

Just overall disappointed I rather cook the meal myself. they were on one.

Just overall very wtf Miami with love, a local.

Cool cozy pizza shop downtown in a not too busy location. Prices are on the higher side but worth it for the hot honey pepperoni which is probably my favorite slice in Miami! I always ask for extra basil and they always give me a bunch! So definitely worth it

Solid NY style pizza. Similar to Joe's quality, with a few nonstandard flavors. Worth checking out if you want decent pizza without waiting in an obnoxious line for their competitor down the street.

I really liked the pizza; we had the cheese and mushroom that was phenomenal. They had a great lager beer too. The restaurant was a bit warm. They also had a great bathroom

I agree that the pizza is really good, however the customer service sucks. They won't take takeout orders over the phone and they also charge a $2 takeout fee if you order at the restaurant.. crazy!

Eleventh Street Pizza in Downtown Miami is more than just another pizza joint; it's a tantalizing journey into the soul of authentic pizza craft. Nestled amidst the urban landscape, it stands out like a beacon for those yearning for the genuine flavors of perfected pie.

Their Pepperoni & Hot Honey pizza is, in many ways, a harmonious rebellion. The classic pepperoni melds with the unexpected heat of the honey, creating an electrifying taste that's as audacious as it is classic. It's reminiscent of those unexpected, serendipitous moments that we travelers live for.

But it's the Carmine Cheese pizza that keeps calling me back. It's my personal sanctuary, a beautiful symphony of creamy cheese on a canvas of crispy, golden crust. Each bite is a comforting embrace, reminding me of the simple pleasures that often have the deepest impact.

The service is an elegant dance of promptness, warmth, and genuine passion for the craft. Every interaction feels tailored, making the culinary journey feel personal.

Ambiance-wise, Eleventh Street effortlessly marries the vibrant energy of Downtown Miami with the cozy nooks of an old-world Italian pizzeria. It's a place where every seat offers an invitation to indulge and reminisce.

In short, Eleventh Street Pizza is a testament to the art of pizza-making. With its impeccable service, inviting ambiance, and slices that speak to the soul, it stands tall as a must-visit gem in Miami's crown.

Ok let's talk about the pepperoni Sicilian. This is a good pizza. Nice sauce when you add al lil honey. Good crunchy buttery crust. I'm very picky.

5 star food, 5 star service, 3 star ambience: Terrific unusual pizza with great service even late at night in a mildly sketchy neighborhood.

5 star food: We had an amazing couple of combination pizzas by the slice. The best slice, heated from a pre-cooked case, was pepperoni drizzled with honey (I know it sounds like tunafish mixed with orange juice or something, but this was really really good : )

5 star service: Both the chef and the counterman were friendly and helpful. The chef even came out to ask how we liked the food and was funny and personable.

3 star ambience: Inside it has a charming hole in the wall late night vibe (it was roughly midnight-1AM I think). Outside it's definitely a neighborhood in transition but has a dangerous edge.